Air source heat pumps

Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum

Help Support Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Aug 17, 2019
Messages
1,615
Reaction score
1,525
Location
Bath
Hive Type
National
Number of Hives
6
Does anyone have any experience of air source heat pumps? Pros and cons please. My parents have been considering one. They currently rely on an oil fired boiler for heating. Thanks
 
There's someone on here who seems to be a bit of a guru in all things solar, ashp etc. so they may be able to help. but for the life of me I cant remember who.

Just hijacking a little rather than create another thread, so if they see this , I too could do with some helpful input too.

I'm looking to the future, and would like some unbiased advice from someone, rather than a salesman, who all seem a bit snake oily on this.
I live in a converted fairly open plan barn, with LPG boiler and wet underfloor heating, plus a log burner, got a few pitched roofs facing wsw, and one small facing due south, so looking to explore all the options.
 
I'm looking to the future, and would like some unbiased advice from someone, rather than a salesman, who all seem a bit snake oily on this.
.

you need a very well-insulated property to start with. For old properties such as ours that's quite a stumbling block.

James
Yes, soon after ASHPumps come in about 10 years ago we were visited by a pair of salesmen who tried to persuade us that our dwelling would be ideal - despite the fact that our property is 600 years old, of wattle and daub construction, and inevitably poorly insulated.......
BTW, at least it is still standing and waterproof - unlike our local hospital, built 1970s, which is ""promised"" for replacement because of RACC
 
Last edited:
Does anyone have any experience of air source heat pumps? Pros and cons please. My parents have been considering one. They currently rely on an oil fired boiler for heating. Thanks
I instaled my ASHP to my ex local authority semi 10 years ago and it has been as efficient and cost effective as gas. (I also have gas at the property so could have installed standard gas CH but as my company was selling renewables at the time I though I should put my money where my mouth was.)
To ensure the heating is effective the house has to be insulated to the best you can get it. Walls, floors and roof.
You will need radiators approximately twice the size of ones for gas/oil as the flow temperatures will be half.
When I installed mine I got the RHI which meant that systems (including insulation) had to be between 240 & 370% efficient which dictated the size of the RHI.
Living with an ASHP is slightly different as background temperatures have to be maintained and windows are rarely opened wide during winter as recovery time is long with low flow temperatures.
IMHO if you can insulate a property well and you are heating with oil or lpg at present you can’t lose with a ASHP
I would recommend getting several companies to quote and compare their designs.
 
Does anyone have any experience of air source heat pumps? Pros and cons please. My parents have been considering one. They currently rely on an oil fired boiler for heating. Thanks
Yes (spit). My old oil boiler was approaching end of life and I filled in an enquiry on line which resulted in a few companies making contact. I went with Greener Living from Sheffield who talked all the right talk, had a energy efficiency survey carried out and had a lot of favourable trustpilot comments AT THE TIME. The sub contract installation team were tidy and carried out their job efficiently. Unfortunately GL commissioning abilities were inadequate. We spent months living in sub-comfort temperatures and despite many complaints no remedial works. Finally I involved the national registration bodies. NAPIT took them to task and kicked them into action. I had a visit from a guy who seemed to be the only knowledgeable member of the team. He identified missing items and when this was rectified the house became warm again but because more energy was being pumped into the house the electric bills rose accordingly. Running costs even now are slightly higher than they were with oil. Fortunately the RHI grants were still available so over 7 years I get progressive payments towards the capital outlay. I used my own bank for a loan and the RHI covers the repayments. Candidly I'd simply replace the oil boiler with a condensing model now. I'm told GL have now gone bust.
No doubt there are satisfied heat pump users but I'm not one. Oh and finally. building regulations prohibit going back from ASHP to oil once you make the switch.
Apparently the same crew have started up as Eco services. See trustpilot reviews https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/greenerliving.co.uk
 
Last edited:
Yes, had one for eight years in a solid wall house built in the 1850s .
Do not get quotes from plumbers
Get quotes from professionals
Get as much insulation as you can as part of the deal.
If it is radiators then either make single ones double or get larger ones
If it under floor heating then make sure all pipe work is suitable.
If you can afford PV panels and batteries these help keep costs down
Pros ... Best thing we ever did, no smell if oil, no fumes, no naked lights, better for the environment, easy to control. Keeps house at a lovely steady temperature
Cons ..... If it is very cold for a few days it can be expensive but does even out over the year
You need to have some knowledge of the workings to be able to tweak it for your comfort and keep costs down
It really comes into its own with PV and batteries and being able to use cheap rate electric from overnight to run it during the day
It is not a cheap alternative but it is comparable
There are many cowboys out there, be careful
There is loads of bad press
Would we change it? Never, I think it's brilliant
 

Latest posts

Back
Top