Can bees identify their keeper by smell?

Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum

Help Support Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

The Riviera Kid

House Bee
Joined
Jul 6, 2010
Messages
247
Reaction score
0
Location
Leicestershire
Hive Type
National
Number of Hives
4
I was talking about honeybees to my 12 year-old nephew (he wants to be an entomologist when he grows up) and discussing their keen sense of smell and he asked if they are able to identify their keeper by smell and whether, over time, they will recognise the keeper as "friendly" and be more likely to ignore the keeper when doing inpections.

I have absolutely no idea.

Can/do they distinguish between humans by smell? When I go to the hive do they go: "No panic. It's only him again"? :)
 
Fascinating question.
My idea is that bees given their "own choice" would rather be left alone and would resent any intrusion. As for recognising their keeper as friend, well, they would have to have less friendly comparisons.
With a life of only six weeks how many are they likely to get?
 
I Can/do they distinguish between humans by smell? When I go to the hive do they go: "No panic. It's only him again"? :)

My 50 years experience is: "Yes, there he comes! Let him run first "!

I have heard that many times how they shout it.
 
Last edited:
Mine seem to like the smell of OH's hair products. Either that or it's scout bees thinking her curly locks look like a good place to swarm to!
 
Bees have been proven to be able to distinguish human faces by sight and remember them.
Derek


The Journal of Experimental Biology 208, 4709-4714
Published by The Company of Biologists 2005
doi:10.1242/jeb.01929
Recognising individuals using facial cues is an
important ability. There is evidence that the mammalian
brain may have specialised neural circuitry for face
recognition tasks, although some recent work questions
these findings. Thus, to understand if recognising human
faces does require species-specific neural processing, it is
important to know if non-human animals might be able to
solve this difficult spatial task. Honeybees (Apis mellifera)
were tested to evaluate whether an animal with no
evolutionary history for discriminating between humanoid
faces may be able to learn this task. Using differential
conditioning, individual bees were trained to visit target
face stimuli and to avoid similar distractor stimuli from a
standard face recognition test used in human psychology.
Performance was evaluated in non-rewarded trials and
bees discriminated the target face from a similar
distractor with greater than 80% accuracy. When novel
distractors were used, bees also demonstrated a high level
of choices for the target face, indicating an ability for face
recognition. When the stimuli were rotated by 180° there
was a large drop in performance, indicating a possible
disruption to configural type visual processing.
Key words: visual processing, face recognition, honeybee, brain.
Summary
Introduction
Honeybee (Apis mellifera) vision can discriminate between and recognise images
of human faces
Adrian G. Dyer1,2,*, Christa Neumeyer1 and Lars Chittka3
 
Last edited:
individual bees were trained to visit target
face stimuli

I really hope mine are too thick to learn this, I don't want my face visited by any bees, however friendly!

More seriously I suspect they do recognise people, they give me no trouble when I sit by the hive watching them, but I'm not sure that when I'm gowned up they realise it's the same person. No proof, just an instinctive feeling, which is one reason why I talk to them. but do they recognise my voice?

All in all a fascinating topic that I often ponder. ;)
 
I seem to remember somewhere reading, or hearing of, a beekeeper who tried sticking his photo to the underside of the crownboard so the bees got used to his face and wouldn't be so disturbed next time he looked in. Pretty sure whoever it was, was barking.
 
I seem to remember somewhere reading, or hearing of, a beekeeper who tried sticking his photo to the underside of the crownboard so the bees got used to his face and wouldn't be so disturbed next time he looked in. Pretty sure whoever it was, was barking.
We were told last week that bees are deaf
 
I seem to remember somewhere reading, or hearing of, a beekeeper who tried sticking his photo to the underside of the crownboard so the bees got used to his face and wouldn't be so disturbed next time he looked in. Pretty sure whoever it was, was barking.
That would be Mr.Jack Russell then
 
Mine seem to like the smell of OH's hair products. Either that or it's scout bees thinking her curly locks look like a good place to swarm to!

Mine always go for my O/H's curly hair too, and none of the rest of us.
 
Bees have been proven to be able to distinguish human faces by sight and remember them.
Derek

Recognising individuals using facial cues is an
important ability... bees also demonstrated a high level
of choices for the target face, indicating an ability for face
recognition.

I am continually astonished by their abilities! not worthy
 
Thus, to understand if recognising human
faces does require species-specific neural processing,

It is known that a human has a face recistry in brains. Data is as karikatyr type in brains and capacity is about 1,5 million faces.

Another recistry in human and animal brains is landscape registry. With that animal finds its nest and can arrive every year to its nesting area.

http://www.newsmap.se/Article.aspx?m=927996&m1=927996&start=40&search=

What its the advantage to bees generate human face registry into brains when human has not much existed in honey bee's life.

.
 
Mine definately can't by sight but I have imperial evidence that they recognise me by touch. Sadly they do this with their sting though. :rolleyes:
 
It's amazing to read that bees can recognise faces.

Regarding my original question about if bees use smell to distinguish humans from each other (and other animals) it seems that they can be trained to recognise certain smells (e.g. drugs, explosives) as described here:

http://www.thenakedscientists.com/HTML/articles/article/humble-honey-bee-in-national-security/

From this it could be that the bees *do* learn the smell of their keeper... but could associate it with disruption to the hive :( so it might not be a good thing after all...

If anyone has a more detailed scientific answer then I would be very grateful. Google draws a blank...
 
Does this mean I'll be able to train them to recognise the mother-in-law and see 'er off? :rolleyes:
 
If anyone has a more detailed scientific answer then I would be very grateful. Google draws a blank...

That is an old fairytale among beekeepers. There is no reason why bees should know the beekeeper.

The hive gets every day in summer 1000 new bees, and 1000 bees die every day. Think about how much fine memories go to the sky of bees!

You go out to your garden and 50 000 bees shout together HIIIIII!!!
Like in China military army parade.... I would like that on my balcony.

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1vA4T1wfJLE[/ame]
 
That is an old fairytale among beekeepers. There is no reason why bees should know the beekeeper.

The hive gets every day in summer 1000 new bees, and 1000 bees die every day. Think about how much fine memories go to the sky of bees!

You go out to your garden and 50 000 bees shout together HIIIIII!!!
Like in China military army parade.... I would like that on my balcony.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1vA4T1wfJLE

Microwave dinners for their husbands tonight! Such precision, scary really.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top