Bcrazy I think you are in many ways missing the point. Committee's, elections et al sum up everything that is wrong with the current organisation. The way i see it is as follows.
1. Some people will have nothing to do with it, thats their choice.
2.Some will join as an alternative to BBKA membership, for many the insurance arranged through the BBKA is pretty close to creating a monopoly situation and the possibility of abuse of power that can in some situations bring about (chose wording very carefully there)
3.The majority I believe will choose to be members of both, and enjoy benefits from both.
The BBKA is pretty good on education but to be perfectly honest education and insurance aside i see it doing very little else for its members.
David