Dr J.Bell
New Bee
i was not quoting use of treatment during a honey flow, it is only you
Iwould suggest that almost all if not all of the 24,000 of the BBKA member do not test their honey for EC. HMF or Diastase, so i am in the majority of of beekeepers in the uk, Bee farmers and Honey Processor yes, they may be testing but not the 24000 bbka memeber. Complience is just by good beekeeping practice, nothing else except % water content
I am sorry but i dont think you live in the real world of beekeeping in the uk and if you are giving input on the registration of beehive, May the Gods help us
i have put a poll up, lets see how the forum responds
you said I was irresponsible for suggesting people use natural essential oils to treat disease, you also stated this was illegal. I simply pointed out that apart from bees collecting some them naturally (if available) there is no law that says you can not use them. Now whey up the irresponsibility of something that wouldnt affect honey, to selling honey to members of the public without even knowing if it conforms to legal requirements!
The fact your telling me most dont do basic testing and yet sell to the public i find horrifying. The rules on food stuffs are there to protect consumers, are you seriously trying to say its perfectly ok to simply assume your honey complies with the law?
The majority of people speed, this dosnt make it legal nor does it protect from prosecution, god help the beek who has his honey reported because someone 'thinks' it caused stomach upset, it wouldnt matter if the honey was responsible or not, if it was found to not comply the producer would be in serious trouble.
What I have advocated has zero effect on honey, it can be effective and even if it was found in your hive how would it be proved that the bees didnt feed on the parent plant?
One last question. since most of the tests would be simple and cheap to do, why do beeks consider it unreasonable to do them and yet sell the honey?
I am extremely interested in the poll, if what you say is correct then this is certainly something i will raise with associations and the relevant government departments.
As for living in the real world, you quoted law to me, and stated there was no requirement to test, did you not? I then pointed out the while the law dosnt say you must test, what it does say is honey must m,eet the standards i have posted, by default the only way to be sure you are legally complying and selling honey fit for consumption is to test it, or do you have another way or working out the EC for example by merely looking at it?
If honey is compliment then why should any food producer comply with the legal standards? what make beeks so special they assume to be above the law? And yes I am involved in the new legal framework, and from what your telling me, yes god help you
Last edited: