Honey stirrer for drill?

Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum

Help Support Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I use a Brawn HAND BLENDER METAL CHOPPING SHAFT. Take the white bit off the end and it fits in a drill.]

I used the "Winker method" last year. Put on reverse drill and it made creamed honey the consistency of double thick cream. All for roughly £15.
 
I had been hoping that something like this => http://www.toolstation.com/shop/p24985
a drill specifically sold for mixing duty ... might do the job for £40.

The other option is to try and attach the Thorne stirrer to a Lidl/Aldi stirrer in place of its non-food-safe paddle.

The same item was £30 from Toolbox! For the sake of £30, I thought it was worth a go.
 

I can't see the impellor shape. But "ring style" sounds like a shielded propellor of some sort - which I understand to be good at entraining air unless kept completely submerged (which implies needing a big mixing vessel and hoping that the surface layer will mix in nicely.
Since it has to be started submerged, you are probably looking at a 'soft-start' drill to drive the thing.
Its in the USA, so shipping charges are going to be significant on something of this weight and size. You might (or might not) find you are faced with a VAT and Duty bill, pus a fee to a freight clearing agent. Its going to cost more than the basic ticket price!

Why would you think it a better drill attachment than the (broadly similar ticket price) Thorne corkscrew?
I don't see the corkscrew as being started or run fully submerged (let alone needing to be) - hence the drill requirements should be more modest than for a propellor. The load on the drill would be changed by varying the length of screw in the honey. All of which seems pretty straightforward - in advance of trying it for myself! :)
 
As has been mentioned before, the impellor type here in the UK at thornes are at least £70 + carr and people are using allsorts of alternatives including plaster and paint mixers because the simple truth is they can't or don't want to pay that much for something used so little. Even the corkscrew at nearly £30 when you add carriage is a lot and it still imparts air into the mixture. My calculations are (having bought lots of stuff from the states) I can get it here for less than what the cost of a corkscrew is from T's. You pays your money you takes your chance
 
Sorry, but my major question is why (for a couple of hives) you would even consider an impellor-type mixer?
While I would suppose that it might give more thorough (thus quicker) mixing, I also think that would only apply to large batches. For a small batch, my expectation (experience anyone?) would be that they would be an air-entrainment liability.
The second problem that I would forsee would be that, in order to minimise air entrainment, the motor would have to be started with the impellor fully submerged It would have to be started against a considerable resistance. Which is precisely how one would burn out a conventional drill. And hence, an impellor-type attachment would demand a more expensive drill.

On the other hand, the corkscrew type, while admittedly giving less vigorous mixing, is therefore going to require less torque to drive it, going to entrain very little air and can be started with little or none of the screw below the surface -- so it can be started under little or no load, which should be, allround a much better match for a conventional (cheap) drill.
The slower (gentler) mixing of small batches is hardly a disadvantage for the domestic "2-hive" hobbyist.

Expressed another way, even if Thorne's £70 impellor cost the same £20 as the corkscrew, my expectation is that the corkscrew would still be the better choice for thee and me.
Why do you think the impellor is better for you?

And having also bought a variety of stuff from abroad, while airmailed small jiffybags can be astonishingly cheap, even the weight of a book costs a lot. The packed weight of a yard-long stainless shaft is going to make it either expensive, or very very slow!
I tend to discount the cost of delivery from T's because rather than buying individual bits, I generally 'batch up' an order, sometimes with friends, to get to the £100. All too easily done!
 
The OP was cost driven and was added to again to find something also cheaper as it was never fully answered prior to this. All I have done is search the www and found this as a potential alternative at a competitive price.

The answer is infinitely indeterminable, I was toying with buying an industrial sized mixer from bankrupt stock to do it with if I could find one at the right price.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top