Paradise or abelo poly national.

Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum

Help Support Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Should be £30 less for a paying into a propriety system IMO.

Yes, that's the main issue here isn't it.

12 frames will attract some people I guess, as will top bee space. But Paradise already offer the latter (also with interlocking boxes), at a much lower price.

Dunno - might be a hit, or might not.
 
I think the Paradise kit is generally overlooked in the UK, probably back from when it was first available here. There was so much resistance to "THE LIP", but this is now seen as a plus to prevent water ingress and provided stability.

My hives are standing the test of time so far at 12 years old, plus time timber stuff is starting to get cut up for firewood and replace with poly.

Most nucs have a lip and even Abelo are reinventing their hives to include this, the paradise does offer a good degree of compatibility. I look at this a little more commercially that I want a system to work with.

I don't want to chop and change but to standardise, in that respect the paradise is a good option with standard hive parts that work together even when they have seen some updates.

The Paradise honey hives are using by the millions worldwide and as a system of working is hugely successful and popular.
 
1. Mitchell D. 2016 Ratios of colony mass to thermal conductance of tree and man-made nest enclosures of Apis mellifera: implications for survival, clustering, humidity regulation and Varroa destructor. Int. J. Biometeorol. 60, 629–638. (doi:10.1007/s00484-015-1057-z)
The tests were conducted in 2012 -2013
 
1. Mitchell D. 2016 Ratios of colony mass to thermal conductance of tree and man-made nest enclosures of Apis mellifera: implications for survival, clustering, humidity regulation and Varroa destructor. Int. J. Biometeorol. 60, 629–638. (doi:10.1007/s00484-015-1057-z)
The tests were conducted in 2012 -2013

That's not a link :)
 
Interestingly expanded polystyrene doesnt change much with density so its all down to thickness and elimination of cold spots from things like hand holds

That's interesting. As it happens I was comparing the thickness of my new Abelo poly hive today with the thickness of a Paynes hive I have. I wasn't entirely comfortable with the result. There are some areas on the Abelo which are only 1.8cm thick (vs min 2.7cm width on the Paynes). They aren't very large areas - the handholds, as you say, but they are large enough. Would this be a problem do you think?

The weight of an Abelo super is 1.35kg, vs 1.63kg for the Paynes, despite the poly being 60% denser, if that helps.
 
Interestingly expanded polystyrene doesnt change much with density so its all down to thickness and elimination of cold spots from things like hand holds
Intriguing, Derek.

I recall ITLD describing a sweet spot between density, weight and insulation value at about 120g/l.
Early poly - I've just been cleaning out some Park boxes - were 100 and relatively soft. By comparison, Abelo's steam-moulded poly is 160g/l.
 
increases density increases toughness but increases weight for same volume, more weight means more cost, more volume means more insulation.
Hence ITLD's sweet spot.
 
increases density increases toughness but increases weight for same volume, more weight means more cost, more volume means more insulation.
Hence ITLD's sweet spot.

Are you saying that the insulation provided by two pieces of poly of identical thickness is the same, regardless of the density of the poly?
 
That's interesting. As it happens I was comparing the thickness of my new Abelo poly hive today with the thickness of a Paynes hive I have. I wasn't entirely comfortable with the result. There are some areas on the Abelo which are only 1.8cm thick (vs min 2.7cm width on the Paynes). They aren't very large areas - the handholds, as you say, but they are large enough. Would this be a problem do you think?

The weight of an Abelo super is 1.35kg, vs 1.63kg for the Paynes, despite the poly being 60% denser, if that helps.
That would imply that the Abelo has very much less expanded foam in its construction which might imply less insulation... but it would have to be tested
 

Latest posts

Back
Top