Question re winter losses

[steve1958]

All my colonies survived the winter and are currently working really well.
They are all on National Brood and a half plus one super.

Last year I fed my bees HiveAlive for the first time, and so far am pleased with the results.
My question is this
Did anyone feed HiveAlive to their colonies last year and still suffer significant losses

 

[Ian123]

I’m sure lots of these additions are fine but probably not worth the money, many on here add thymol to syrup and are happy with results.

 

[jenkinsbrynmair]

the only effective ingredient of hive alive is thymol anyway

 

[steve1958]

Maybe
But my question is Did anyone feed HiveAlive to their colonies last year and still suffer significant losses

 

[Erichalfbee]

You’d have to add to your data
Did anybody not feed Hive Alive and suffer no losses?

 

[steve1958]

No.
All I am asking is

Did anyone feed HiveAlive to their colonies last year and still suffer significant losses.

If no one did then that's fine.

 

[Erichalfbee]

No.
All I am asking is

Did anyone feed HiveAlive to their colonies last year and still suffer significant losses.

If no one did then that's fine.

If you like I can put this into the main beekeeping section where more people can see it?

 

[steve1958]

If you like I can put this into the main beekeeping section where more people can see it?

Yes please